Facilities Managers as an Undocumented Immigrant or DACA Recipient

Jan 17, 2024

19 Min Read

1. What is an undocumented immigrant and how does someone become one?


An undocumented immigrant, also known as an illegal or unauthorized immigrant, is a foreign-born individual who is residing in a country without proper legal authorization. This person may have entered the country without inspection (often referred to as “illegally”), overstayed their visa, or violated some other immigration law.

There are several ways someone can become an undocumented immigrant. These include:

1. Entering the country without proper documentation or inspection: This means they did not go through a designated port of entry and were not inspected by immigration officials upon entering the country.

2. Overstaying a visa: If someone enters the country legally with a visa but remains in the country after their authorized stay has expired, they become an undocumented immigrant.

3. Violating the terms of a visa: If someone enters the country with a valid visa but engages in activities that are not allowed under that specific visa category (e.g. working on a tourist visa), they can become an undocumented immigrant.

4. Expired or revoked immigration status: When someone’s legal status expires or is revoked for any reason (e.g. failure to renew), they become undocumented.

5. Human trafficking or smuggling: In some cases, individuals may be deceived or forced into entering a country illegally by human traffickers or smugglers, making them undocumented immigrants.

It’s important to note that becoming an undocumented immigrant does not happen overnight – it can be a result of multiple factors and circumstances over time.

2. Can an undocumented immigrant hold a job as a Facilities Manager?


Undocumented immigrants do not have the legal right to work in the United States, so they cannot hold any job that requires authorization or documentation of employment. This includes positions like Facilities Manager, as it is a skilled professional role that typically requires documentation and legal status.

3. Are there any specific requirements for an undocumented immigrant to work as a Facilities Manager?


No, there are no specific requirements for an undocumented immigrant to work as a Facilities Manager. However, they must have the necessary skills and qualifications required for the job, such as experience in facilities management, knowledge of building codes and regulations, and excellent communication and organizational skills. Additionally, they must have a valid Social Security number or Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) to legally work in the United States.

4. What kind of challenges might an undocumented immigrant face while working as a Facilities Manager?


1. Legal Aspects: Undocumented immigrants have limited or no legal rights and protections in the United States, which could make it difficult for them to assert their rights as employees. They are vulnerable to exploitation and may not have access to basic labor protections such as minimum wage, overtime pay, or workplace safety regulations.

2. Language Barriers: Many undocumented immigrants may face challenges due to language barriers while working as a Facilities Manager. This can create communication issues with colleagues, contractors, and clients which could lead to misunderstandings, delays, and mistakes.

3. Limited Job Opportunities: Being undocumented makes it difficult for immigrants to find good job opportunities. Facilities Management roles often require specific qualifications and certifications which may not be recognized for undocumented immigrants.

4. Discrimination & Harassment: Some individuals may discriminate against undocumented immigrants simply due to their status, resulting in a hostile work environment. They may also face harassment or even threats of deportation from coworkers or employers.

5. Fear of Detection and Deportation: Undocumented workers live with a constant fear of being caught by immigration authorities, which can affect their mental well-being and work performance.

6. Difficulty in Advancement: Undocumented immigrants often do not have the necessary documents or qualifications required for career advancement in their field. This lack of opportunities can be demotivating and frustrating for individuals looking to grow in their careers.

7. Lack of Access to Benefits: Due to their undocumented status, these workers may not have access to employee benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, vacation days, sick leave etc., making it challenging to manage personal/family needs effectively while balancing work responsibilities.

8. Social Stigma & Isolation: Undocumented immigrants face social stigma due to widespread negative perceptions about immigration. This can lead to feelings of isolation at work and difficulties in building professional relationships.

9. Criminalization: Federal policies such as E-Verify require employers to verify an employee’s eligibility to work in the United States, thereby criminalizing undocumented individuals and leading to decreased job opportunities.

10. Limited Job Security: Due to their undocumented status, these workers may not have any legal protection against termination. They can be fired at any time without any recourse, leaving them vulnerable and uncertain about their future employment prospects.

5. Do Facilities Management companies have policies in place to accommodate undocumented immigrants or DACA recipients?


It is standard practice for Facilities Management companies to follow all federal and state laws regarding employment, including those related to immigration status. This may include verifying employment eligibility through the Form I-9 process and adhering to any federal or state requirements regarding hiring undocumented immigrants or DACA recipients. Companies may also have their own policies in place to ensure compliance with these laws and protect the rights of their employees. It is recommended that individuals reach out directly to specific Facilities Management companies for more information about their policies regarding undocumented immigrants or DACA recipients.

6. How does an undocumented immigrant obtain necessary certifications or licenses to work as a Facilities Manager?


Since undocumented immigrants are not legally eligible to work and often face barriers in obtaining certifications or licenses, it can be challenging for them to work as a Facilities Manager. However, there may be some options available depending on the individual’s circumstances.

1. Look for employers who do not require documentation status: Some employers may be willing to hire undocumented immigrants and may not require legal documentation during the hiring process. This could potentially provide an opportunity to work as a Facilities Manager without needing any additional certifications or licenses.

2. Consider alternative job titles: Instead of working as a Facilities Manager, an undocumented immigrant could consider alternative job titles such as building maintenance worker, building manager, or property manager. These roles may not have the same certification or licensing requirements and could potentially offer similar job duties.

3. Obtain necessary qualifications through education and experience: Depending on the state where the individual resides, they may be able to obtain necessary qualifications for a Facilities Manager role through educational programs or work experience. For example, some community colleges or vocational schools offer certificate programs in facilities management that do not have citizenship requirements.

4. Explore avenues for obtaining legal status: If an undocumented immigrant is interested in pursuing long-term employment opportunities as a Facilities Manager, they may want to explore avenues for obtaining legal status in their country of residence. This could include seeking employment-based visas or applying for permanent residency through family sponsorship.

5. Connect with organizations that support undocumented workers: There are various non-profit organizations that provide resources and support to help undocumented workers find employment opportunities and navigate potential barriers they may face. These organizations may be able to offer guidance on how an individual can overcome challenges related to certification or licensing processes.

Overall, it is important for undocumented immigrants seeking employment as a Facilities Manager to research and understand their options carefully and consult with legal professionals when necessary.

7. Are there any legal risks for a company hiring or employing an undocumented immigrant as a Facilities Manager?


Yes, there are several legal risks for a company hiring or employing an undocumented immigrant as a Facilities Manager.

1. Violation of immigration laws: It is illegal for employers to knowingly hire or employ individuals who are not authorized to work in the United States. By hiring an undocumented immigrant, the company would be violating federal immigration laws and could face penalties, fines, and/or criminal charges.

2. Liability for wage and labor violations: Undocumented immigrants are protected by the same wage and labor laws as U.S. citizens and legal residents. If the company does not pay them minimum wage, overtime, or provide other benefits required by law, they could face lawsuits and fines from government agencies such as the Department of Labor.

3. Discrimination claims: Hiring only undocumented immigrants for certain positions could lead to discrimination claims from qualified legal residents or citizens who were not considered for the job.

4. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) violations: If an undocumented Facilities Manager is injured on the job due to unsafe working conditions, the employer could be held liable for violating OSHA regulations.

5. Tax and IRS penalties: Employers are required to report employment taxes for all employees through tax forms such as W-2s or 1099s. Failure to do so can result in penalties from the IRS.

6. Reputational damage: Hiring undocumented immigrants can also lead to negative publicity and damage the company’s reputation among customers, investors, and potential employees.

7. Risk of deportation: If an employee is found to be working without authorization, they can be deported by immigration authorities. This could result in disruption of operations and potential loss of specialized skills or knowledge that may be difficult to replace quickly.

8. How do the labor laws and regulations apply to undocumented immigrants working in the Facilities Management industry?


Undocumented immigrants working in the Facilities Management industry are entitled to labor protections and may have certain legal rights despite their immigration status. However, their specific rights and protections may vary depending on state and federal laws and regulations.

1. Minimum Wage Laws: Undocumented immigrants are protected by minimum wage laws, which require employers to pay them the same minimum wage as any other employee. This means they cannot be paid less than the legally required minimum wage for their work, regardless of their immigration status.

2. Overtime Laws: Similar to minimum wage laws, undocumented immigrants are entitled to overtime pay if they work more than 40 hours per week. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) requires employers to pay covered employees at least one-and-a-half times their regular rate of pay for all hours worked over 40 in a workweek.

3. Workplace Safety and Health Regulations: Undocumented workers are covered by Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) regulations, which provide guidelines for safe working conditions and protection against hazards in the workplace. This means that employers must ensure a safe working environment for all employees, regardless of their immigration status.

4. Discrimination Protections: Both federal and state laws prohibit employment discrimination based on race or national origin, which includes discrimination against undocumented workers. This means that employers cannot refuse to hire an individual, fire them, or treat them unfairly due to their immigration status.

5. Anti-Retaliation Provisions: Undocumented workers have the right to report unsafe working conditions or workplace violations without fear of retaliation from their employer. This includes reporting wage theft or filing a complaint with OSHA.

6. Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA): While IRCA makes it illegal for employers to knowingly hire or continue employing individuals who are not authorized to work in the United States, it also prohibits employer discrimination based on citizenship or immigration status.

7. Employee Benefits: In most cases, undocumented workers are not entitled to the same benefits as legally authorized workers. However, they may still be eligible for certain benefits such as workers’ compensation if they are injured on the job.

8. Right to Organize: Undocumented workers have the right to join or form labor unions and participate in collective bargaining agreements, according to the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). This means they can negotiate for better working conditions and higher wages.

In summary, while undocumented immigrants technically do not have work authorization, they are still protected by various labor laws and regulations in the Facilities Management industry. Employers must ensure that all employees, regardless of their immigration status, are treated fairly and provided with a safe working environment.

9. Can an employer discriminate against an employee based on their immigration status, even if they are qualified for the job?

No, employers cannot discriminate against employees based on their immigration status. The federal Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) prohibits discrimination in hiring, firing, or recruitment based on a person’s citizenship or immigration status.
Employers are only allowed to ask about a person’s immigration status for specific purposes, such as verifying work eligibility. They must treat all individuals equally and cannot use an employee’s immigration status as a factor in employment decisions.
An individual who is otherwise qualified for a job should not be denied the opportunity to work based on their immigration status. If an employer engages in discriminatory practices, the affected individual can file a complaint with the Department of Justice’s Immigrant and Employee Rights Section or seek legal action through other avenues.

10. What steps can an undocumented immigrant take to protect their employment rights as a Facilities Manager?


1. Research your rights: Educate yourself on the legal protections available to undocumented immigrants in the workplace. This includes understanding labor laws, minimum wage requirements, and anti-discrimination policies.

2. Keep documentation: It is important to have a record of all your employment documents, such as paystubs, work contracts, and any other relevant paperwork. These will serve as evidence of your employment and can protect you in case of any disputes.

3. Understand company policies: Make sure you are familiar with your company’s internal policies regarding employee rights and discrimination. This will help you identify any potential violations of your rights.

4. Seek legal advice: Consider consulting with an immigration lawyer who can advise you on your specific situation and provide guidance on how to protect your rights as an undocumented immigrant working as a Facilities Manager.

5. Be aware of your surroundings: Monitor for any suspicious or discriminatory behavior in the workplace and take note of any incidents or comments that may seem discriminatory towards you or other employees.

6. Communicate effectively: Don’t be afraid to speak up and communicate clearly with your supervisor about any concerns or issues that may arise in the workplace. It is important to address these issues promptly before they escalate.

7. Document incidents: If you experience discrimination or harassment at work, document the details including dates, times, and witnesses present. This information can be used as evidence if needed.

8. Join a union: Unions can provide support for workers’ rights and often have resources available specifically for undocumented workers.

9. Explore alternative options: If you feel that your employer is not respecting your rights as an undocumented worker, consider seeking alternative employment opportunities where you feel more secure and valued.

10.Try to obtain legal status: Although this may not be an immediate solution, obtaining legal status through avenues such as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) or applying for a green card can provide more protections for your employment rights as a Facilities Manager.

11. Is it possible for an employer to sponsor an undocumented employee for citizenship or legal residency status while employed as a Facilities Manager?

No, it is not possible for an employer to sponsor an undocumented employee for citizenship or legal residency status while employed as a Facilities Manager. In order to sponsor an employee for immigration benefits, the employer must first verify the employee’s eligibility to work in the United States. This includes providing proper documentation and completing Form I-9. If an employee does not have legal authorization to work in the US, they are not eligible for sponsorship by their employer.

12. How do continuous changes in immigration policies impact the job security of an undocumented individual working as a Facilities Manager?


Continuous changes in immigration policies can have a significant impact on the job security of an undocumented individual working as a Facilities Manager. This is because they are at risk of facing deportation if they are discovered and do not have proper documentation to work legally in the country.

One possible scenario is that the individual could be terminated from their job if their employer becomes aware of their undocumented status. In this case, the individual would lose their income and potentially struggle to find another job without proper documentation.

Another potential impact is that changing policies may limit opportunities for career advancement or professional development for undocumented individuals. They may not be able to obtain certain certifications or licenses required for higher-level positions due to their status, which could hinder their ability to move up in their field.

Additionally, frequent policy changes can create confusion and uncertainty for undocumented individuals, leading to fear and anxiety about losing their job or being deported. This can lead to stress and distraction at work, potentially affecting job performance and potentially putting them at risk of being let go.

Overall, continuous changes in immigration policies can greatly affect the job security of undocumented individuals working as Facilities Managers, making it difficult for them to maintain stable employment and advance in their careers.

13. Are there any resources available to help educate and support employers who want to hire, employ, or promote employees regardless of their immigration status, including those wishing to become Facility Managers?


Yes, there are several resources available to help educate and support employers who want to hire, employ, or promote employees regardless of their immigration status. These include:

1. The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) website: This website provides information on the rules and regulations surrounding the employment of individuals with different immigration statuses, as well as guidance on completing employment eligibility verification forms.

2. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) website: The EEOC is responsible for enforcing federal laws that make it illegal to discriminate against job applicants or employees based on their national origin or citizenship status. Their website offers resources and guidance on these laws.

3. The National Immigration Law Center (NILC): NILC provides training and resources for employers regarding the rights of immigrant workers in the workplace.

4. Local immigrant rights organizations: Many local organizations focus on providing support and education for immigrant communities, including helping them navigate the job market. They may have resources specifically geared towards educating employers about hiring individuals regardless of their immigration status.

5. Consult with legal counsel: Employers can also consult with an attorney who specializes in immigration law to ensure they are following all relevant laws and regulations when it comes to employing individuals with different immigration statuses.

Additionally, there may be state or local government agencies that offer workshops or trainings for employers on hiring practices that promote diversity and inclusion, including hiring individuals regardless of their immigration status. Employers can also reach out to industry associations for resources and advice on best practices for promoting diversity in the workplace.

14. Can DACA recipients work in roles such as Facilities Management that may require knowledge of sensitive information or access to specialized technology?


DACA recipients are legally allowed to work in any profession, including roles such as Facilities Management, as long as they meet the qualifications and requirements for the job. They may also be subject to background checks and security clearances like any other employee in similar positions. As long as they have valid work authorization documents and follow all relevant laws and regulations, there should be no restrictions on their ability to perform these roles.

15. How can facilities management companies ensure compliance with state and federal laws regarding employment equality and fair treatment of all employees, regardless of immigration status?


1. Implement company policies and procedures: Develop clear and explicit policies and procedures that outline the company’s commitment to diversity, equality, and fair treatment of all employees. This should include provisions for fair hiring, promotion, training, and discipline processes.

2. Provide training: Train human resources staff, managers, and supervisors on state and federal laws related to employment equality and non-discrimination. This will help ensure that they are aware of their legal obligations and can prevent any potential discrimination or bias towards employees based on immigration status.

3. Conduct regular audits: Regularly review hiring practices, employee records, payroll records, and other relevant documents to ensure compliance with state and federal laws regarding employment equality.

4. Maintain accurate records: Keep accurate records of employee information such as immigration status, work authorization documents, and social security numbers in accordance with applicable laws.

5. Use E-verify: If required by state law or the federal government, use the Department of Homeland Security’s E-Verify program to verify the eligibility of newly hired employees to work in the United States.

6. Consult legal counsel: Work with a lawyer who is knowledgeable about immigration laws to ensure compliance with rules surrounding employment of immigrants.

7. Educate employees: Educate all employees about their rights in the workplace regardless of their immigration status. This can be achieved through seminars or training sessions conducted throughout the year.

8. Be proactive against discrimination: Create a safe environment where employees feel comfortable reporting any incidents of discrimination or harassment based on their immigration status without fear of retaliation.

9. Monitor subcontractors: If using subcontractors for certain tasks or projects, make sure they comply with all applicable labor laws including equal employment opportunities for immigrants.

10.Be transparent: Ensure transparency in communicating company policies related to immigrant workers to avoid any misunderstandings or confusion among employees.

11.Lead by example: Foster an inclusive culture by promoting diversity within the organization’s leadership team as well as among employees at all levels.

12.Communicate openly: Keep an open line of communication between management and employees. This will help address any concerns or issues related to employment equality and immigration status.

13. Offer resources for immigrant employees: Consider providing resources such as language classes, legal aid, or other support services to help immigrant employees integrate into the workforce and their community.

14. Regularly revisit policies: Continuously review and update company policies to ensure they are aligned with state and federal laws concerning employment equality and immigration.

15. Seek expert guidance: Seek guidance from experts such as attorneys or human resource professionals who are well-versed in state and federal laws related to employment equality and immigration. They can provide valuable insights and advice on how to comply with these laws effectively.

16. Are there any common misconceptions about employing or working with undocumented immigrants in the facilities management industry?


There are several common misconceptions about employing or working with undocumented immigrants in the facilities management industry, including:

1. They take away jobs from U.S. citizens: One of the biggest misconceptions is that undocumented immigrants are taking jobs away from American workers. However, studies have shown that they often work in jobs that Americans do not want and can help to fill labor shortages in various industries.

2. They do not pay taxes: Another misconception is that undocumented immigrants do not pay taxes. In reality, many undocumented workers pay income taxes using an ITIN (Individual Taxpayer Identification Number) and contribute to Social Security and Medicare through payroll taxes, even though they may not be eligible for these benefits.

3. They are a burden on public services: There is a belief that undocumented immigrants drain public services and resources such as healthcare and education. However, research has shown that they actually contribute more in taxes than they receive in benefits.

4. They are more likely to commit crimes: Many people believe that immigrants, especially those who are undocumented, are more likely to commit crimes. However, numerous studies have shown that immigrants have lower crime rates than native-born citizens.

5. Hiring them is illegal: Some employers may be hesitant to hire undocumented immigrants because they believe it is against the law. It is important to note that under federal law, it is not illegal for private employers to hire undocumented workers as long as they provide proper documentation proving their identity.

6. They cannot speak English: Many people assume that all undocumented immigrants cannot speak English and will therefore struggle in the workplace. However, many of them are bilingual or multilingual and can communicate effectively in English.

7. They receive welfare benefits: Another misconception is that undocumented immigrants receive welfare benefits like food stamps or housing assistance. In reality, most don’t qualify for these benefits because of their immigration status.

It’s important for employers to educate themselves about the realities of employing undocumented immigrants and to understand that they can be a valuable asset to their facilities management team.

17. What steps can facilities management companies take to create inclusive workplaces for individuals from diverse backgrounds, including undocumented immigrants?

1. Educate employees and management on cultural sensitivity and unconscious bias: Facilities management companies can provide training sessions and workshops to help employees understand and recognize their own biases, as well as how to be culturally sensitive in the workplace.
2. Review hiring policies and practices: Companies can review their hiring policies to ensure they are not discriminating against individuals from diverse backgrounds, including undocumented immigrants. They can also actively recruit candidates from underrepresented groups.
3. Create a diversity and inclusion committee: Establishing a committee dedicated to promoting diversity and inclusion in the workplace can help identify areas for improvement and implement initiatives that support individuals from different backgrounds.
4. Offer language access services: Providing translation services, language classes, or interpreters for non-English speaking employees or clients can improve communication and make the workplace more inclusive for individuals from diverse backgrounds.
5. Implement employee resource groups: Employee resource groups (ERGs) are voluntary, employee-led groups that promote diversity and inclusion within an organization. These groups provide a safe space for employees from similar backgrounds to share experiences, connect with others, and advocate for inclusivity in the workplace.
6. Provide mentorship opportunities: Mentoring programs can help create a supportive work environment for individuals from diverse backgrounds by connecting them with experienced professionals who can offer guidance and career development opportunities.
7. Offer equal opportunities for advancement: Facilities management companies should ensure that all employees have equal opportunities for advancement, regardless of their background or immigration status.
8. Partner with community organizations: Companies can partner with community organizations that support immigrant communities to provide resources and support to their employees.
9. Establish clear anti-discrimination policies: Facilities management companies should have clear policies in place prohibiting discrimination based on factors such as immigration status, national origin, race, religion, etc.
10. Foster an inclusive company culture: Companies should foster a culture of inclusivity where all employees feel valued and respected regardless of their background or immigration status.

18. Do undocumented immigrants have access to the same training and development opportunities as other employees in the facilities management industry?


No, undocumented immigrants do not have access to the same training and development opportunities as other employees in the facilities management industry. This is because their status as undocumented immigrants prevents them from legally being hired for these positions. Employers are required to verify an employee’s eligibility to work in the United States, which undocumented immigrants would not be able to provide. As a result, they are often limited to low-skilled, low-paying jobs without much room for advancement or training. Additionally, some companies may also have policies prohibiting the hiring of undocumented immigrants due to legal and ethical considerations.

19. How has the current political climate affected the employment opportunities for undocumented immigrants seeking careers in facilities management?


The current political climate has significantly affected the employment opportunities for undocumented immigrants seeking careers in facilities management. The implementation of stricter immigration policies and increased enforcement measures have made it more difficult for undocumented immigrants to secure employment in the United States.

One of the major impacts is the decrease in job opportunities as many employers are now required to verify an employee’s legal status before hiring them. This makes it harder for undocumented immigrants to find work, especially in fields where background checks and proof of legal status are mandatory, such as facilities management.

Additionally, some states have passed laws that impose penalties on businesses that hire undocumented workers, making employers hesitant to hire or retain employees without proper documentation.

Furthermore, with a heightened focus on immigration enforcement, undocumented workers may be at risk of deportation if they come forward or are identified by their employers.

These factors have limited the job options for undocumented immigrants seeking careers in facilities management and have created a challenging environment for them to secure stable and well-paying jobs in this field.

20. Do facilities management companies have a responsibility to advocate for fair immigration policies and support their undocumented employees?


Facilities management companies have a responsibility to follow all relevant laws and regulations related to employment, including immigration policies. This includes properly documenting and verifying the legal status of their employees. However, facilities management companies are not typically involved in advocating for or creating immigration policies. It is important for companies to treat all employees with fairness and respect, regardless of their immigration status, and to comply with any laws or regulations that apply to their business. If facilities management companies have undocumented employees, they should also provide resources and support to help them navigate the complexities of their situation and ensure fair treatment in the workplace.

0 Comments

Stay Connected with the Latest